Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Doctors, Mans and Captains: Generic Descriptions


Comic books are rife with heroes with colorful names. But it seems a majority of characters are simply a description of what they do and who they are. Spider-Man, SuperMAN, BatMAN, Animal MAN for pete’s sake. Etc. Sometimes they get creative like The Human Torch but that’s just a less gender specific word for man and switching the order between man and thing. While I give huge credit to the creativity of the characters, there seems to be a lack of skill in the naming department.

Now when comic book super heroes first arrived on the scene, they were primarily aimed at children. As any parent or childcare person can tell you, you need to keep things simple with children. The younger they are, the harder it is for them to deal with complex concepts and ideas. That’s one of the driving forces for the initial popularity of a character like Superman. He is dressed in primary colors with simple powers, such as super strength and speed. It is easy to see the initial appeal of those early fans.

While the idea of characters calling themselves “______” Man, I am even more annoyed by characters who call themselves Doctor “_______”. I have many friends who have worked hard for the past several years to become an actual doctor. They have worked hard to earn the right to use that descriptor. Many of the characters in comics who refer to themselves as Doctor, have no such degree. Even a character like Doctor Strange, who does have a legit medical degree, should no longer refer to himself as Doctor since he has long since stopped practicing any form of medicine.  

Doctor Doom never even got a medical degree. He dropped out of college after a horrible accident (that’s why he wears the mask). He then became the despotic ruler of his home country of Latveria through a combination of science and sorcery. While all that is an impressive accomplishment, still he never finished college. Of course, Mister Doom doesn’t quite have the same ring to it.

As opposed to Doctor Doom, Captain American is an actual Army Captain. Steve Rogers has the rank of captain with all the privileges and responsibilities that rank implies. Though the very fact that he has that rank seems to imply a bit of corruption in the armed forces of the Marvel Universe. I mean, prior to becoming Captain America, Steve Rogers was a puny weakling who was classified 4F and unfit for service. It was only due to the injection of the Super Soldier Serum that he was able to become Captain America. But he didn’t really earn that rank. It’s not like he started out as Private America and then climbed the ranks to Captain. They gave him the rank of Captain without him having performed any service to earn such  rank.

Union Jack
In the comics, just like in reality, Captain America was created as propaganda. He was created during a time of war to inspire Americans to feel a renewed sense of pride in their country.  In the comics he was supposed to be the first of an entire battalion of super soldiers but the scientist who created the formula was murdered. And so Steve Rogers was left as the only successfully created Super-Soldier. Now being the ultimate American soldier someone decided to slap a flag on him and use him as a symbol. Sadly, many other countries decided to follow suit. There are several national heroes of multiple countries, each really just being a thinly veiled copy of Captain America. There is a Captain Britain, though the British equivalent of Captain America would be Union Jack, a costumed super spy. Captain Britain is more an inter-dimensional protector seeped in Arthurian mythology.
"Have no fear. Captain Canuck is here!"

Over the years, comics have had brief periods of stagnation. These periods of stagnation have seen the industry nearly vanish from existence. The usual thing that saves comics from going extinct is the introduction of some new way to tell these mythic stories of heroes. Finding a new way of looking at the characters that had not previously been considered (usually by a British writer). Perhaps one of the inciting causes of these stagnation periods is that writers get lazy. They come up with a simple concept and give a character a generic name, causing the stories to never evolve into something the readers have not seen before. And thus the readers abandon their beloved funny books in search of more innovative sources of entertainment.

No comments:

Post a Comment